The Spin Multiplicity window allows you to select only physically meaningful combinations of open shells and multiplicity. To select a combination of spin multiplicity/no. of open shells, you must click on the diamond corresponding to your choice.
Note that in some cases portions of the spin diagram below the diagonal may be disabled, even though these states are physically meaningful. The reason for this is that most open shell Hartree-Fock (HF) programs are limited to handling only high spin states. For example, if there were 4 open shells in a molecule, most HF programs would be able to handle only the quintet state (not the triplet or singlet). In order to access the triplet and singlet states, it would be necessary to use an HF program that allowed such states, or resort to a Generalized Valence Bond (GVB) theory, instead of ROHF. Where there are multiple spin states possible (e.g., there are 3 ways of constructing a triplet state with 4 open shells), you will have to input spin coupling coefficients in order to have the GVB code solve for the correct state.